The Fractional CMO Playbook: When to Hire One & What ROI to Expect [Podcast Ep. 15]
Are you feeling stretched thin managing your marketing on top of everything else? You’re not alone – and as Dylan Bennett shared on the Simply Smart Business podcast, that’s exactly where a fractional CMO can step in and deliver real results for growing businesses.
Let’s break down what a fractional CMO actually does, why small and midsize companies are increasingly turning to this flexible leadership model, and how Dylan’s hands-on approach delivers focus, strategy, and growth – without the price tag of a full-time exec.
Watch the podcast video here:
Listen to the podcast here:
What Is a Fractional CMO?
A fractional CMO is your “chief marketing officer,” just not on your payroll full-time. Dylan described it simply: “I function as your CMO, but only part-time. I’m not a dedicated member of your team, but I lead your department.”
He fills the leadership and strategy gap, guiding marketing just as a permanent executive would, but in a way that matches your business’s needs and budget.
Here’s what that looks like in practice:
▷ Stepping in as the leader for your marketing department, no matter your business size
▷ Creating strategy, setting goals, tracking KPIs, and making sure execution gets done
▷ Supporting your team – hiring, training, or even managing contractors and vendors
▷ Guiding your business through periods of transition, scaling, or new market entry—without locking you into a full-time hire
Dylan emphasized that many small businesses simply don’t need, or can’t afford, an in-house CMO, but that “doesn’t mean they don’t need the expertise.”
Who Should Consider a Fractional CMO?
Dylan works with owners and teams who are great at what they do, but not necessarily at marketing. Maybe you’re a founder who wears too many hats, your marketing feels fragmented, or your current team doesn’t have strategic experience.
You’re ready for a fractional CMO if:
▷ You have a team (or want to assemble one) but lack strategic leadership
▷ Marketing tasks are taking you away from running your business
▷ You want to grow and need marketing guidance without hiring full-time senior staff
▷ You’re overwhelmed by marketing decisions and want a seasoned roadmap
▷ You want to make data-driven choices but need help setting up tracking and metrics
As Dylan put it, “I help with strategy… the whole nine yards in terms of what a normal CMO would do, but only part-time.”
What Does a Fractional CMO Do Day to Day?
Dylan highlighted several roles he fills as a fractional CMO:
1. Strategic Oversight
He leads marketing strategy—setting direction, choosing the right channels (social, email, SEO, etc.), and making sure every campaign aligns with business objectives.
2. Team Leadership & Training
Dylan mentors, hires, and trains team members. For some companies, he helps build a marketing department from scratch; for others, he plugs into an existing team to boost results.
3. Execution & Systems
He doesn’t just create strategies—he rolls up his sleeves and gets processes in place, so marketing gets done, week after week. Think: workflow checklists, templates, and a structured content calendar.
4. KPIs & Reporting
With digital marketing, everything is measurable. Dylan sets up dashboards so you aren’t guessing whether marketing is working. He reviews campaign metrics and adjusts tactics so your spend translates to real leads and sales.
5. Scalability
Whether your business is growing, shifting, or just needs stability, a fractional CMO offers the expertise to adapt quickly. Dylan’s approach includes making himself “redundant,” so as your in-house team gains confidence, you aren’t dependent on outside help forever.
Fractional vs. Full-Time CMO: Cost & Commitment
Hiring a CMO full-time could run from $180K to $300K+ per year, plus benefits. Dylan’s fractional engagements usually run 1–3 days per week or on a project/retainer basis, often at a fraction of the total cost of bringing someone in full-time.
The benefits to your business are immediate:
▷ Senior leadership and marketing expertise
▷ No payroll overhead or long-term employment contracts
▷ Flexible engagement – ramp up or down as needed
Dylan explained, “I’m not on your payroll technically, but I function as a leader for that department… The only real cost is your time and how to learn how to do it”…unless you want someone to build the playbook for you.
Measuring ROI: What Should You Track?
Dylan is a big believer in “actionable metrics.” Why? Because digital marketing lets you see exactly what’s working. Here’s what you’ll want to track:
▷ Website traffic and conversions
▷ Social and email engagement
▷ Leads and sales directly from your campaigns
▷ Cost per lead and cost per acquisition
▷ Results from specific workflows/systems (i.e., content repurposing, as Dylan outlined)
Dylan points out that with digital, “You post something on Instagram or YouTube, you’re seeing exactly how many people saw it… how many clicked… every single step.” You can identify weaknesses quickly and focus your efforts on what actually drives results.
Are You Ready for a Fractional CMO? [Checklist]
Here’s a quick checklist (based on Dylan’s real client experiences):
🔲 You’re regularly unsure about next steps or priorities in marketing
🔲 Marketing feels sporadic or disconnected from business goals
🔲 You want repeatable systems, not just quick fixes
🔲 You’re willing to dedicate time and attention to leadership meetings each week
🔲 You’re ready to let an expert lead and follow a strategic path
🔲 You have at least some budget for marketing (ad spend, team, or tools)
🔲 You want marketing you can measure – and results you can count on
If you’ve checked at least half these boxes, you may be ready to bring in a fractional CMO and start seeing clearer, more strategic, and ultimately more profitable marketing.
Dylan concludes: “A fractional CMO brings in someone to lead your team with expertise or with some actual background in it. That gives [small businesses] somebody that can lead that team with an area of expertise.” You get access to pro-level guidance, without the risk or expense of a full-timer.
Curious about making this a reality? Connect with Dylan Bennett on LinkedIn or Instagram, or reach out via dybmedia.org to see how a fractional CMO could help you finally nail your marketing, one strategic step at a time.
Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for more episodes packed with actionable marketing tips!